Paraquat resistance
How does paraquat kill
plants?
Paraquat is rapidly absorbed into leaves, especially under conditions of
high temperatures and humidity. Within the cells paraquat moves into the
chloroplasts (Information
on chloroplasts) where it reacts with free electrons from photosynthesis
to produce molecules which destroy the plant's membranes. Sunlight is
necessary for this reaction to occur. This leads to wilting and desiccation
(Movies
on the effect on paraquat), a process that occurs quickly under sunny
warm conditions and slower under low light conditions. Translocation of
paraquat is limited by the speed of damage to plant tissues. For this reason
paraquat is considered a contact herbicide, however application during late
afternoon will allow translocation through the plant during darkness.
Paraquat is most effective when applied to seedlings as they have less
capacity to reshoot when compared with larger plants. Better coverage of the
plant with the herbicide also gives higher levels of control.
Resistance to
paraquat in Australia
Three populations of paraquat-resistant annual ryegrass (Lolium
rigidum) have been confirmed in south eastern South Australia in
2010 by glasshouse experiments. One population is also resistant to
glyphosate. Glyphosate resistance evolved on an irrigation channel and
subsequently moved into the paddock, where it was then selected with
paraquat.
Other species have previously developed resistance to Group L
herbicides in Australia. The first case being northern barley grass in
1983 (Table 1). Small square weed was the first case of resistance
to paraquat in Australia that developed outside of broadacre
agriculture. All cases of resistance to paraquat are in situations with
long histories of use (>15 years).
Table 1. Species that have
developed resistance to paraquat in Australia
|
Species
|
Common
Name |
Year
confirmed
|
State
|
Crop
|
Resistance to other Modes-of-action / herbicides
|
|
Arctotheca
calendula
|
Capeweed
|
1984
|
Victoria
|
lucerne
|
diquat (L)
|
|
Hordeum
glaucum
|
Northern barley grass
|
1983
|
Victoria
|
lucerne
|
diquat (L)
|
|
Hordeum
leporinum
|
Barley grass
|
1988
|
Victoria
|
lucerne
|
diquat (L)
|
|
Lolium
rigidum
|
Wimmera ryegrass
|
2010
|
South Australia
|
pasture seed
|
A
|
|
Lolium
rigidum
|
Wimmera ryegrass
|
2010
|
South Australia
|
pasture seed
|
M
|
|
Mitracarpus
hirtus
|
Small square weed
|
2007
|
Queensland
|
mangoes
|
diquat (L)
|
|
Vulpia
bromoides
|
Silvergrass
|
1990
|
Victoria
|
lucerne
|
diquat (L)
|
<top of page>
World scene
Outside of Australia there are 19 species with confirmed populations
resistant to paraquat. These include 3 grass and 16 broadleaf species.
Paraquat is widely used in tree crops and plantations around the world. The
use of paraquat in no-till farming due has increased markedly in recent
years due to the development weeds with resistance to glyphosate in these
systems.
Table 2. Species that have developed
resistance to paraquat in other countries
|
Species
|
Common Name
|
Country
|
Species
|
Common Name
|
Country
|
|
Amaranthus
blitum
(syn.
A. lividus) |
Livid amaranth
|
Malaysia
|
Ischaemum
rugosum
|
Saramatta grass
|
Malaysia
|
|
Bidens pilosa
|
Cobblers' pegs
|
Kenya
|
Landoltia
punctata
|
Dotted duckweed
|
Florida, USA
|
|
Conyza
bonariensis
|
Flaxleaf fleabane
|
Egypt, Japan, South Africa, California
|
Lepidium
virginicum
|
Virginia peppercress
|
Canada
|
|
Conyza
canadensis
|
Canadian fleabane
|
Japan, Canada, USA, Belgium
|
Lolium
rigidum
|
Wimmera ryegrass
|
South Africa
|
|
Conyza
sumatrensis
|
Tall fleabane
|
Japan, Taiwan, Malaysia, Sri Lanka
|
Monochoria
korsakowii
|
Mizuaoi
|
Japan
|
|
Crassocephalum crepidioides
|
Thickhead
|
Malaysia
|
Poa annua
|
Winter grass
|
UK, Belgium
|
|
Cuphea
carthagenensis
|
Cuphea
|
Fiji
|
Solanum
americanum
(syn.
S. ptychanthum) |
American nightshade / Eastern black nightshade
|
Florida, USA; Canada
|
|
Eleusine
indica
|
Crowsfoot grass
|
Malaysia, Florida
|
Solanum
nigrum
|
Blackberry nightshade
|
Malaysia
|
|
Epilobium
ciliatum
|
American willowherb
|
Belgium, United Kingdom
|
Youngia
japonica
|
Asiatic hawksbeard
|
Japan
|
|
Erigeron
philadelphicus
|
Philadelphia fleabane
|
Japan
|
|
|
|
Source: International Survey of
Herbicide Resistance 2011
<top of page>
Products containing paraquat in Australia Below are
some examples of trade names of herbicides containing paraquat on
the Australian market at time of writing. Paraquat alone - 48
products including: Gramoxone® 250 Herbicide and Nufarm Nuquat® 250
Non-Residual Knockdown Herbicide Paraquat + diquat - 34 products
including: Spray.Seed 250 Herbicide and Nufarm Revolver® Herbicide
Paraquat + amitrole - One product: Crop Care Alliance® Herbicide
<top of page>
Projects in Australia working on paraquat resistance
Risk assessment and management of paraquat resistance in the
pasture seed industry
Rural Industries Research & Development Corporation Project PRJ-006912
Project leader: Chris Preston (University of Adelaide)
Summary: This project is attempting to define the extent of resistance
to paraquat in annual ryegrass in pasture seed production fields. A
survey will be conducted in collaboration with the agronomy companies
(Elders, Landmark, Cox Rural) involved in providing advice to pasture
seed producers in the south east of South Australia and western Wimmera
of Victoria. Seeds will be collected from fields and plants grown from
this seed tested for resistance to paraquat, glyphosate and other
herbicides. Seedlings will be treated with herbicides at the field rate
of products and if more than 20% survive, the populations will be
classed as resistant. The project will examine practices used in the
pasture seed industry to determine the risks of resistance to paraquat
and other herbicides. A survey of seed producers will be conducted in
collaboration with the agronomy companies to look at herbicide and other
practices used in the pasture seed industry to identify practices that
increase resistance risks to the industry and those that decrease risks.
A survey of pasture seed samples will be undertaken to determine the
potential risk of resistant seed movement to other sectors. A workshop
will be held with agronomists, growers and others in the pasture seed
industry to deliver the outcomes of the research and identify strategies
for better managing resistance.
Understanding and Management of Resistance to Group M, Group L and
Group I Herbicides
GRDC Project No: UA00124
Project Leader: Chris Preston, University of Adelaide
Summary: This project will develop better understanding of resistance to
glyphosate, paraquat and Group I herbicides to better inform weed
management. The project will develop a range of tools for farm advisors to
improve their confidence in decision making with respect to reducing the
risk of developing resistance to glyphosate, Group I and paraquat. These
will include risk assessments, case studies and scenario exploring tools.
The project will investigate the potential for alternatives to these
herbicides, concentrating on knockdown uses and other herbicides for
Brassica weeds, which may prove useful in Australian agriculture. Outcomes
will be discussed with commercial providers to explore the potential for
future herbicide registrations. The project will establish farm advisor
learning groups to work on the application of the research in local areas
where resistance is already a major problem and to improve adoption of
research from this and other projects. The outcomes of the project will be
primarily aimed at farm advisors, but will also be of benefit to grain
growers and others in the industry.
<top of page>
Internet Links
Paraquat Information Centre (Syngenta) -
http://paraquat.com/
International Survey of Herbicide Resistance -
http://www.weedscience.org/In.asp
<top of page>
References
Busi, R., Powles, S.B. (2011) Reduced sensitivity to paraquat evolves
under selection with low glyphosate doses in Lolium rigidum. Agronomy
for Sustainable Development, 31, 525-531.
Yu, Q., Huang, S., Powles, S.B. (2010) Direct measurement of paraquat in
leaf protoplasts indicates vacuolar paraquat sequestration as a resistance
mechanism in Lolium rigidum. Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology,
98, 104-109.
Yu, Q., Han, H., Nguyen L., Forster, J.W., Powles, S.B. (2009) Paraquat
resistance in a Lolium rigidum population is governed by one major
nuclear gene. Theoretical & Applied Genetics, 118, 1601-1608.
Preston, C., Soar, C.J., Hidayat, I., Greenfield, K. M., Powles, S.B.
(2005) Differential translocation of paraquat in paraquat-resistant
populations of Hordeum leporinum. Weed Research, 45, 289-295.
Soar, C.J., Karotam, J., Preston, C., Powles, S.B. (2004) Polyamines can
inhibit paraquat toxicity and translocation in the broadleaf weed
Arctotheca calendula. Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology, 80: 94-105.
Yu, Q., Cairns, A., Powles, S.B. (2004) Paraquat resistance in a
population of Lolium rigidum. Functional Plant Biology. 31: 247-254.
Soar, C.J., Karotam, J., Preston, C., Powles, S.B. (2003) Reduced
paraquat translocation in paraquat resistant Arctotheca calendula
(L.) Levyns is a consequence of the primary resistance mechanism not the
cause. Pesticide Biochemistry & Physiology, 76, 91-98.
Alizadeh, H.M, Preston, C., Powles, S.B. (1998) Paraquat resistant
biotypes of Hordeum glaucum from zero tillage wheat. Weed
Research. 38, 139-142.
Purba, E., Preston, C., Powles, S.B. (1996) Growth and competitiveness of
paraquat-resistant and susceptible biotypes of Hordeum leporinum
Link. Weed Research. 36: 311-317.
Purba, E., Preston, C., Powles, S. B. (1995) The mechanism of
resistance to paraquat is strongly temperature dependent in resistant
Hordeum leporinum and Hordeum glaucum. Planta. 196:
464-468.
Preston. C., Balachandran, S., Powles, S. B. (1994) Investigations
of mechanisms of resistance to bipyridyl herbicides in Arctotheca
calendula (L) Levyns. Plant Cell & Env. 17: 1113-1123.
Purba, E., Preston, C., Powles, S.B. (1993) Paraquat resistance in a
biotype of Vulpia bromoides (L) S.F. Gray. Weed Research. 33,
409-413.
Purba, E., Preston, C., Powles, S.B. (1993) Inheritance of bipyridyl
herbicide resistance in Arctotheca calendula and Hordeum leporinum.
Theoretical & Applied Genetics.87, 598-602
Preston, C., Holtum, J.A.M., Powles, S.B. (1992) On the mechanism of
resistance to paraquat in Hordeum glaucum and H. leporinum.
Delayed inhibition of photosynthetic O2 evolution after paraquat
application. Plant Physiol. 100, 630-636.
<top of page>
|